A strong wellness program can enhance employee engagement, reduce burnout, and foster a strong company culture. But this only happens when it’s designed with intention. Many HR teams make the same avoidable mistakes during the planning phase, and those missteps can quietly hold a program back before it even launches.
Here are the top three mistakes HR teams make when planning employee wellness programs, and how to avoid them so your program can support real wellbeing and connection.
1. Not Treating Wellness as More than Physical Health
Many wellness programs still center around movement challenges, water goals, or nutrition education. Those are valuable, but they only cover one part of wellbeing. Today’s workforce is navigating stress, burnout, loneliness, financial pressure, and hybrid-work disconnects, factors that impact health just as much as steps or sleep.
Why this is this a problem
When wellness feels one-dimensional, people tune out, especially employees who don’t identify with physical-activity-based challenges. A holistic approach is more inclusive and more aligned with what modern employees actually need.
What to do instead
Offer a mix of programming that supports:
- Emotional wellbeing: stress awareness, mental health education, mindfulness tools
- Social wellbeing: team-based challenges, connection-building activities
- Financial wellbeing: budgeting guidance, financial planning resources
- Physical wellbeing: activity challenges, sleep education, nutrition support
Wellness should feel practical, relatable, and balanced, not rigid.
2. Launching Without a Clear Communication and Measurement Plan
A wellness program can be thoughtfully built, but if employees don’t understand what’s offered, how to participate, or why it matters, engagement will stay low. Communication determines whether a wellness initiative actually takes off.
Why this is a problem
Employees are busy. Without consistent, clear messaging, even the best wellness program disappears into the background.
What to do instead
Build a simple communication plan that includes:
- A high-level program overview
- Visual quick-start guides
- Multi-channel reminders (email, posters, etc.)
- A cadence for ongoing updates
Then identify a few meaningful metrics to track: participation, repeat engagement, team involvement, employee sentiment, or wellness goal progress. Reviewing these insights regularly helps you evolve the program instead of repeating what isn’t working.
3. Building a Program for Employees Instead of with Employees
One of the biggest reasons wellness programs fall flat is simple: they’re designed without enough employee input. HR teams often rely on assumptions about what people want, but those assumptions don’t always match reality.
Why this is a problem
When employees don’t feel represented, you’ll see low participation, low engagement, and a sense that wellness is something “extra” rather than something meaningful.
What to do instead
- Send a short, focused wellness interest survey
- Ask quick questions during team meetings or listening sessions
- Look at available data (engagement trends, past participation, etc.)
- Invite a small cross-department wellness committee to give feedback
Employee-informed wellness programs feel more inclusive and naturally get higher buy-in. When people see their ideas reflected, wellness becomes something they want to be part of, not something they feel obligated to do.
Final Thoughts
Wellness programs succeed when they feel human, inclusive, and easy to engage with. By avoiding these three common mistakes, HR teams can build programs that support real behavior change and help people feel connected to their workplace.
This is the heart of a strong wellness strategy: not perfection, but intentional design that meets employees where they are.
Interested in our Wellness Programs?
Schedule a demo today to learn how our platform can help you build a wellness program that’s engaging, inclusive, and unforgettable!
